A Christian auto repair company has defeated a racial discrimination lawsuit after refusing to franchise to a religious Jew, in accordance with its longstanding franchise policy of awarding franchises only to professing Christians.
The U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals emphasized that protections against racial discrimination do not also apply to religious discrimination. It also noted that the company has awarded franchises to two ethnic Jews who are professing Christians.
Background
Christian Brothers Automotive Corporation is a Houston-based auto repair business that franchises only to Christians. Its stated mission is to “glorify God by providing ethical and excellent service to its customers.”
In forty years of business, the company has never offered a franchise to someone not “spiritually aligned with the company and prepared to share a personal Christian testimony.” All of its more than 250 franchisees, a group which includes some ethnic Jews, are professing Christians.
Evan Domanic, who is both ethnically and religiously Jewish, applied to open a Christian Brothers franchise in the fall of 2020. During the interview process, Domanic allegedly disclosed that he is Jewish rather than Christian, and was told that religion wouldn’t be an issue. Christian Brothers denies this claim.
In November 2020, Domanic was told that Christian Brothers was ending the hiring process because of his Jewish faith. Two years later, Domanic filed a federal lawsuit against Christian Brothers, claiming racial discrimination.
He alleged that Christian Brothers “denied him a franchise because of his Jewish ethnicity and not his Jewish faith—or that, in any case, there is no meaningful distinction between Jewish ethnicity and religion, regardless of what actually motivated the company’s refusal.”
Christian Brothers sought to have the case dismissed, arguing that it “ended the franchise process based solely on Domanic’s non-Christian faith and not his Jewish ethnicity, of which it was unaware.”
The district court denied this motion, finding that Domanic had sufficiently pled a claim for racial discrimination.
Christian Brothers then moved for summary judgment, arguing that Domanic’s claim was “a religious discrimination claim masquerading as race discrimination.” The company also pointed out that its franchise policy provided a lawful and race-neutral reason for denying Domanic a franchise.
District Judge Drew Tipton agreed, ruling that Christian Brothers showed that its religious franchise policy was a legitimate justification for its actions and that there was no evidence this justification was pretextual.
Domanic appealed to the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans.
The Appeal
On September 30, a three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit affirmed the district court order, concluding that Domanic presented no evidence that Christian Brothers discriminated on the basis of his Jewish ancestry.
Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan explained that U.S. Supreme Court precedent has made clear that Section 1981 of the Civil Rights Act of 1866 only protects “identifiable classes of persons who are subjected to intentional discrimination solely because of their ancestry or ethnic characteristics.” The Supreme Court has also clarified that Section 1981 applies to “Jewish ethnicity or ancestry.”
Domanic contended that “there can be no distinction between discrimination based on Jewish ancestry and discrimination based on Jewish faith,” and that Section 1981 “protect[s] Jews … regardless of whether they are religious or ethnic Jews.”
The panel rejected this argument, concluding that it is “settled that [Section 1981] does not forbid religious discrimination.”
Judge Duncan criticized Domanic’s lack of evidence on appeal that Christian Brothers discriminated on the basis of race.
“Domanic makes no serious effort on appeal to show any error in the district court’s ruling. That is unsurprising,” wrote Duncan. “As discussed, the evidence proved without contradiction that Christian Brothers has a longstanding and consistent policy of franchising only to professing Christians. And no evidence suggested that this policy was a pretext for racial discrimination against persons of Jewish ancestry (or any other ancestry).”
“To the contrary, the undisputed evidence showed that Christian Brothers has franchised to two ethnic Jews who are professing Christians,” he continued.
With Judge Tipton’s order affirmed, the case has been dismissed with prejudice.
If you or anyone you know has information regarding court cases, please contact our tip line: tips@texasscorecard.com.