Webster: The High-Speed Railway To Nowhere

After watching California sink $16 billion into a bullet train that still doesn't exist, an Austin Democrat now wants Texas to do likewise.

Texas Democrats just watched California spend two decades and over $15 billion on a high-speed rail line that doesn’t exist, and their reaction was basically, “Hold my beer, we can do it even worse.”

House Bill 270 was filed by an Austin Democrat named John Bucy. He wants TxDOT to team up with a private company on a Dallas-to-San Antonio high-speed rail that runs through Waco and Austin along I-35. He claims the train will go as fast as 110 mph. The bill also kills the 2017 law that kept the state from dumping money into private high-speed rail projects. No price tag. No deadline. Just a polite suggestion that Texas get in the high-speed train business before the consultants run out of lunch receipts.

California’s version of this boondoggle is the gift that keeps on taking. Voters signed off on a $10 billion project back in 2008. That liberal wet dream was supposed to go from San Francisco to Los Angeles and should have been completed by 2020. Eighteen years and $16 billion later, there is still no high-speed rail.

State officials keep saying they might start laying actual track before the year ends, but it’s going to cost just a tiny little more money when it’s eventually completed. How much more for the whole system? Anywhere from $126 billion to $231 billion, which means probably closer to $300 billion if I had to guess. That’s basically California’s entire annual budget.

California is the model Texas is being asked to copy. A “public-private partnership” where “private” sounds like the word that keeps the taxpayers calm right up until the private partner needs a public bailout. But Texas already tried this little experiment, and it failed miserably. The private Dallas-to-Houston effort spent years in court over eminent domain (that’s when the government takes your stuff and chooses the price to repay you without asking you first). Costs climbed past $30 billion, federal planning money was lost, Amtrak was bailed out, and they still haven’t put down one inch of railroad track.

Rural landowners fought this nonsense for years because why wouldn’t they? They’re the ones whose lives will be uprooted if this project ever happens. Fortunately for them, it didn’t work in the past, and it won’t work in the future.

But this time it’s going to be different, they’ve assured us. Of course it will. You trust our new Texas government, right?

HB 270’s route runs straight up the middle of the state.

That means more hearings, more surveys, more “we need this strip of your ranch for the greater good,” and more lawsuits that will outlast the time it would take actually to build the thing.

Eminent domain is the part of the discussion the politicians always forget to mention. When the government gets to legally steal your land and repay you with a price of their choosing, it’s never going to end well. It’s the state, or a company with the state’s blessing, deciding your property is more useful as a right-of-way than as a working ranch or a house you actually live in (or the place where you buried your grandma). You get a modest check; they get your multigenerational home.

California already showed us what happens when a high-speed rail project is being (not so) seriously considered: everything slows down, and the bills keep adding up. Texas is denser in spots and just as lawsuit-happy, which is a polite way of saying the lawyers are already sharpening their pencils and booking conference rooms at the local Marriott. Nobody will get a high-speed rail, but plenty of fast-talking bureaucrats will get rich off the conversations.

Texas spent decades building and maintaining a highway system that actually moves people and freight without turning our state into a multi-decade monument to optimistic PowerPoint presentations. We don’t need to fix something that isn’t broken. California proved real Americans don’t need or want high-speed rail lines, and Texas still has time to look at reality and decide whether “let’s try it anyway” is a mistake we’ll regret for years.