A federal appellate court has reinstated claims in a case alleging that Eyemart Express disclosed private health information to Meta. The proposed class action lawsuit was previously dismissed by a lower court.
The U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals concluded that the plaintiffs’ initial pleadings sufficiently alleged that they had shared private health data with Eyemart, and that this data was then shared with Meta without their knowledge or consent for purposes of targeted marketing.
Background
Eyemart Express, based in Farmers Branch, is a national eyewear chain that owns and operates physical stores as well as a website.
The website utilizes Meta’s internet tracking tool, called “the Meta Pixel.” Websites add the tool to their pages and can control what information it discloses and whether any data is encrypted. With this browsing information, Meta creates profiles, which it then uses to send targeted advertisements to users.
Companies like Eyemart gain more insights into their own advertising efforts and can improve their targeted advertising by purchasing ads through Meta. This arrangement has been described as incentivizing “both Meta and sites like Eyemart to collect as much information as possible.”
Without users’ consent or knowledge, Eyemart reportedly allows the Pixel to track users’ searches, clicks, product viewing information, and appointment scheduling information from the site, giving that data to Meta.
The Lawsuit
This led five Facebook users who reportedly used Eyemart’s website to file a federal lawsuit against Eyemart under state and federal wiretap laws, as well as privacy and breach-of-contract claims.
The suit alleged that the information the Pixel tracked from the site, related to viewing and purchasing prescription eyeglasses and scheduling eye exams, qualifies as “private health information” that Eyemart should not have permitted Meta to access without their knowledge or consent.
Specifically, the plaintiffs contended that this information meets the definition of individually identifiable health information (IIHI) protected under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA) and is therefore the type of private information entitled to protection from unauthorized disclosure.
HIPAA defines IIHI as “any information, including demographic information collected from an individual,” that “is created or received by a health care provider, health plan, employer, or health care clearinghouse” and “relates to the past, present, or future physical or mental health or condition of an individual, the provision of health care to an individual, or the past, present, or future payment for the provision of health care to an individual” and “identifies the individual” or “with respect to which there is a reasonable basis to believe that the information can be used to identify the individual.”
Notably, the plaintiffs are divided into two categories.
The “search plaintiffs” allegedly used the site to browse and search for prescription glasses, which triggered the Pixel to track their activity and share it with Meta. The “prescription plaintiffs” allegedly purchased prescription eyewear from Eyemart, which required entering their prescription information into the site, which was then shared with Meta through the Pixel.
Eyemart sought to have the case dismissed, arguing that the plaintiffs failed to state a claim. This is when the facts alleged in the complaint, even if taken as true, do not provide a sufficient legal basis for relief.
U.S. District Judge David Godbey agreed, dismissing the case with prejudice. He concluded that the search plaintiffs failed to adequately allege that they shared any IIHI with Eyemart. As for the prescription plaintiffs, Godbey acknowledged that they shared IIHI with Eyemart but they failed to show that any IIHI was disclosed to Meta.
The plaintiffs appealed this decision to the U.S. Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans, asserting that both groups shared their IIHI with Eyemart and that it was then shared with Meta. Eyemart disagrees, also arguing that the case should be dismissed for a lack of standing because the plaintiffs failed to allege a concrete injury.
The Ruling
On October 23, a three-judge panel of the Fifth Circuit ruled that the plaintiffs have standing and adequately pleaded that they shared IIHI with Eyemart and that the IIHI belonging to both the search plaintiffs and prescription plaintiffs was subsequently shared with Meta.
“[A]ccording to the Amended Complaint, the Pixel (and therefore Meta) received data about the vision products Plaintiffs viewed, their prescription eyewear purchases, their appointment details, and other IIHI,” wrote Judge Stephen Higginson. “Taking these factual allegations as true, and making all reasonable inferences in Plaintiffs’ favor, Plaintiffs have adequately alleged that, by using the Pixel, Eyemart shared Plaintiffs’ IIHI with Meta without their consent.”
The panel acknowledged that “without the benefit of discovery, Plaintiffs cannot be expected to know much more at this early stage.”
The district court dismissal was therefore reversed, and the case was remanded to proceed on the merits.
Should the plaintiffs prevail, the ruling could change how health-related businesses use the Meta Pixel. Rather than abandon such a popular tool for online advertising, businesses may need to limit the information the Pixel sends to Meta and give website visitors clear notice about what data is shared.
If you or anyone you know has information regarding court cases, please contact our tip line: tips@texasscorecard.com.