Paxton Appeals Federal Court Order Blocking ActBlue Lawsuit

The attorney general is seeking to revive Texas’ case accusing the Democrat fundraising platform of misleading consumers about its donation safeguards.

ActBlue Website

Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton is asking a federal appeals court to revive his office’s legal fight against Democrat fundraising giant ActBlue.

Paxton filed an opening brief with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit challenging a Massachusetts federal judge’s decision that prevents his office from proceeding with a Texas consumer protection lawsuit against the fundraising platform.

The original lawsuit, filed in Tarrant County in April, accuses ActBlue of violating the Texas Deceptive Trade Practices Act by misleading consumers about safeguards intended to prevent fraudulent and potentially illegal political donations.

ActBlue has processed more than $16 billion in political donations since its founding in 2004 and is a major fundraising platform for Democrat candidates and causes.

At the center of Paxton’s lawsuit are allegations involving gift cards and prepaid debit cards, payment methods that can make it more difficult to verify the identity of a donor.

ActBlue had represented, amid scrutiny from Congress and investigators, that it strengthened its safeguards and stopped accepting gift card donations.

However, investigators with Paxton’s office say they were subsequently able to make multiple donations through the platform using gift cards—including one purchased with cash and made under a pseudonym.

ActBlue responded to the Texas lawsuit by suing Paxton in federal court in Massachusetts.

In June, a federal district judge issued a preliminary injunction preventing Paxton and his office from continuing to litigate the Texas case or bringing another state enforcement action based on the same conduct.

Paxton is now asking the First Circuit to reverse that ruling.

His office argues that the Massachusetts court improperly interfered with an ongoing state court proceeding involving Texas’ enforcement of its own consumer protection laws. Paxton also contends the court lacked jurisdiction over his office and that Massachusetts was an improper venue for ActBlue’s claims.

“A federal court in Massachusetts is wrong to prevent Texas from enforcing its own consumer protection laws against entities doing business in our State,” said Paxton.

“ActBlue represented that it no longer accepted gift card donations, yet our investigators successfully made multiple gift card donations through its platform,” he added. “We will fight for our right to hold companies accountable when they misrepresent the services that they provide to Texans.”

Paxton is asking the appeals court to reverse the preliminary injunction and direct the Massachusetts district court to dismiss ActBlue’s federal lawsuit.

ActBlue previously characterized Paxton’s lawsuit as politically motivated.

“This is a thinly veiled attempt to distract from Ken Paxton’s numerous legal and ethical issues ahead of next month’s runoff,” ActBlue spokesperson De’Andra Roberts-LaBoo told Texas Scorecard after the lawsuit was filed in April.

“If he and his Republican allies actually cared about donor fraud, they would work to strengthen security standards across the board, including within their own operations, rather than targeting ActBlue,” she added. “Our platform has done more than any other, regardless of party, to prevent improper donations and protect donors. Full stop.”

Texas Scorecard reached out to ActBlue for comment on Paxton’s appeal and whether the organization disputes the state’s account of investigators successfully making gift card donations after ActBlue said it had stopped accepting them.